Buffalo Nickel: List of Rare and Valuable Coins
The Buffalo Nickel, which became minted between 1913 and 1938, is considered one of America’s most coveted cash. While many of these cash are not unusual, a number of the rarest variations have risen in value over time. Due to minting errors, low manufacturing numbers, and unique characteristics, these few Buffalo Nickels could be really worth hundreds of thousands of greenbacks nowadays.
If you’ve got an antique Buffalo Nickel, you want to examine it carefully. Here is a listing of the 7 maximum rare and valuable Buffalo Nickels that would be well worth a mixed total of over $1 million.
1918/7-D (Overdate Error)
This coin is one of America’s most famous error coins. The Denver Mint accidentally overdated it as 1918 while reusing a 1917 die. This rare coin is very valuable to collectors.
- Minute Number: Unknown (due to error)
- Estimated Value: Up to $350,000 in high grades
1916 (Doubled Die Obverse)
This Buffalo Nickel features a Doubled Die Obverse in which the coin’s date appears slightly doubled. This was caused by a glitch in the minting process, making it rare and collectible.
- Minute Number: Unknown (due to error)
- Estimated Value: Up to $281,000 (in Mint condition)
1926-S (Lowest Mint Number Variant)
The 1926-S version is one of the least produced coins in the Buffalo Nickel series. Most of this year’s coins were widely circulated, making any coin remaining in good condition extremely valuable.
- Minute Number: 970,000
- Estimated Value: Up to $322,000 (in Mint condition)
1937-D (Three-Legged Buffalo Nickel)
This coin is called the “Three-Legged Buffalo” because excessive die polishing at the Denver Mint caused part of one of the buffalo’s legs to be erased. This flaw makes the coin extremely rare and collectible.
- Minute Number: Unknown (due to error)
- Estimated Value: Up to $150,000 (in high grades)
1936-D (Three-and-Half Legs Version)
This coin is similar to the 1937-D version, but is missing only half of one of the buffalo’s legs. While it is less valuable than the three-legged version, it is still worth significantly more.
- Minute Number: Unknown (due to error)
- Estimated Value: Up to $21,000 (in Mint condition)
1914/3 (Overdate Error)
This coin was created when a 1913 die was reused as a 1914 die. If you look closely, a faint “3” can be seen below the “4”. This makes this coin rare and valuable.
- Minute Number: Unknown (due to error)
- Estimated Value: Up to $7,000 (in high grades)
1935 (Doubled Die Reverse)
This coin has a special feature called the Doubled Die Reverse, which means that the letters and designs on the back of the coin appear to be printed twice. If found in good condition, it can fetch a very high price.
- Minute Number: Unknown (due to error)
- Estimated Value: Up to $104,650 (in mint condition)
Do you have any rare Buffalo Nickel
The Buffalo Nickel series has many rare coins that can be worth millions of dollars. If you have a collection of old coins, examine them carefully—because it could be a priceless treasure!
If you are interested in coin collecting or investing, it pays to keep abreast of market value and consult professional coin experts to help you get the most out of your collectible coins.